Frequently asked questions
-
The San Francisco Sourdough Collective is a free online community for home sourdough bakers of all skill levels. Members get access to instructional videos, recipes, in-person events, and a community of people who love to bake. It is a project of Boudin Bakery, San Francisco’s original sourdough bakery, founded in 1849.
-
Joining is free. Just create an account on this site to access our library of instructional videos, recipes, and upcoming events.
-
San Francisco sourdough is known for its distinctly tangy flavor, developed through its starter and a long, slow fermentation process. The city’s climate and rich baking history helped make this style of sourdough famous. Boudin Bakery continues to bake with a portion of its original mother dough dating back to 1849.
-
A sourdough starter is made by combining flour and water and allowing naturally occurring yeast and bacteria to ferment the mixture. Feed it regularly with fresh flour and water until it becomes active, bubbly, and reliably doubles in size after feeding. This may take a week, two weeks, or longer depending on the conditions in your kitchen.
-
A healthy sourdough starter should rise predictably after feeding, smell pleasantly tangy or yeasty, and show visible bubbles throughout. Depending on the feeding ratio and room temperature, an active starter will often double in size within 4 to 8 hours. A sharp, nail polish remover-like smell or a layer of liquid on top usually means it is hungry and needs to be fed. However, if you see mold or pink or orange discoloration, discard the starter and begin again.
-
Common causes include an underactive starter, dough that is too cold, or not allowing enough fermentation time. Use a starter that rises predictably after feeding and is at or near its peak when added to the dough. A warm environment of around 75 to 78 degrees Fahrenheit can also help fermentation progress more reliably. Keep in mind that timing will vary depending on your recipe, ingredients, and kitchen temperature.
-
Bread flour is a popular choice because its higher protein content creates a stronger gluten structure, helping the dough hold its shape and rise well. All-purpose flour can work too, especially for beginners. Many bakers also add a portion of whole wheat or rye flour for additional flavor and fermentation activity.
-
Many sourdough recipes take 24 to 48 hours from start to finish, but most of that time is hands-off fermentation. The process generally includes mixing, bulk fermentation, shaping, a final proof (often overnight in the refrigerator) and baking. Exact timing will vary depending on the recipe, starter strength, and temperature.
-
Yes. A Dutch oven is popular because it traps steam, helping the bread expand and develop a crisp crust, but it is not the only option. You can bake on a preheated baking stone, baking steel, or sturdy sheet pan and place a separate metal pan of hot water in the oven to create steam. A covered, oven-safe roasting pan can also work well.
-
For short-term storage, place the loaf cut-side down on a cutting board or keep it in a bread box, cloth bag, or paper bag at room temperature. This helps preserve the crust, although the bread will gradually become drier. A plastic or airtight bag will keep the bread softer but will also soften the crust. For longer storage, slice the bread, freeze it in an airtight bag, and toast individual slices directly from frozen.